Humanitarian Response in Conflict Zones: Are We Failing?
By Tahir Ali Shah
The world’s conflict zones are becoming increasingly
perilous, posing unprecedented challenges to humanitarian efforts. From the
bombed-out streets of Gaza to the desolate landscapes of Sudan, the frozen
battlegrounds of Ukraine, and the famine-stricken villages of Yemen, aid
organizations face mounting obstacles. The core principles of humanitarian work,
neutrality, impartiality, and independence, are under siege. Humanitarian
workers are being killed, aid convoys looted, and entire populations cut off
from life-saving assistance. Are we failing those who need us most?
Imagine being trapped in a besieged city, running out of
food, water, and medicine, only to discover that the promised international aid
will never arrive. This grim scenario is the daily reality for millions of
civilians in modern wars.
In Gaza, Israel’s blockade since October 2023 has choked the
flow of aid to a trickle. According to the United Nations Relief and Works
Agency (UNRWA), over 80% of Gazans rely on humanitarian assistance, yet less
than 10% of the required aid gets through each day. Starvation is a looming
catastrophe.
The crisis is equally dire in Sudan. Fighting between the
Sudanese Armed Forces (SAF) and the Rapid Support Forces (RSF) has displaced
over 8 million people, with humanitarian convoys regularly hijacked or blocked.
In Darfur, entire communities are left to fend for themselves amid ceaseless
violence. Alarmingly, 30 million people in Sudan are in need of humanitarian
assistance, with nearly 25 million experiencing acute food insecurity.
Ukraine presents yet another grim tableau. Over 17 million
Ukrainians need humanitarian aid, but attacks on convoys have rendered it
almost impossible to reach those trapped behind enemy lines. Meanwhile, in
Yemen, nearly a decade of war has plunged 17 million people into food
insecurity, with 2.2 million children acutely malnourished. Aid blockades
imposed by both the Saudi-led coalition and Houthi rebels have weaponized
hunger.
The peril of being an aid worker has reached unprecedented
levels. Humanitarian principles, designed to shield those delivering lifesaving
assistance, are now disregarded.
In Gaza, 196 UNRWA staff have been killed since October
2023—the highest toll ever suffered by UN workers in a single conflict. Sudan
is no different; aid convoys have been ambushed, and workers killed in the line
of duty. Ukraine’s war zones see aid workers targeted, with missile strikes
claiming the lives of volunteers delivering food. Yemen is equally devastating,
where more than 150 aid workers have lost their lives since 2015.
Humanitarian work demands neutrality, yet conflicts today
relentlessly politicize aid. In Gaza, accusations of UNRWA links to Hamas have
led to funding cuts, crippling relief efforts. Sudan’s warring factions hoard
and divert aid, leaving civilians to starve. In Ukraine, so-called
"humanitarian corridors" have been weaponized to forcibly relocate
civilians. Yemen’s Houthi rebels obstruct aid deliveries and impose illegal
taxes, turning humanitarian assistance into a bargaining chip.
The international community cannot stand idle. Four urgent
actions are imperative. 1. The Geneva Conventions must be upheld, and violators
held accountable by the UN and the International Criminal Court (ICC). 2. Humanitarian
response plans, like the UN’s for Sudan, remain grossly underfunded. For
example, the 2025 plan for Sudan is funded at only 5.8%, leaving
millions without support. 3. Governments and agencies must prioritize safer
protocols and explore remote assistance options to reduce risk, and 4. Aid
funding and distribution must remain independent of political agendas, ensuring
that the focus remains solely on need.
The harsh truth is that we are failing. Aid organizations
are striving heroically, but the insurmountable challenges of restricted
access, security risks, and political interference thwart their efforts. At its
core, this crisis is not just a matter of policy or funding; it is a question
of shared humanity.
Will the world choose to act, or will we consign millions to
suffer in silence? The answer to this question defines not only the future of
humanitarianism but the moral fabric of our global society.
Tahir Ali Shah is a humanitarian professional with over 25
years of experience managing protection and development programs across South
Asia, the Middle East, and Africa. tshaha@gmail.com
Comments